Another View of Agile

Posted in Introspect on 01 27th, 2012 | your response

Power to the Edge: Command and Control in the Information Age, speaks to the integration of traditional management with complex systems in the presence of agility, emergence, and variability of the real world.

This is a book about managing in the defense systems domain and the technology advances that push the decision making processes to the edge of system.

This is about architecture of the system. The human system, the techncial system, the operational system, and the governance system, and the environment in which these systems are embedded.

While the book is focused on military systems, it is applicable to other complex systems. Military systems have many if not most of the attributes of business systems.

They have strategy, emerging requirements, adversaries who want to put you at a disadvantage, limited budgets, limited time to deploy the solution, conflicts internally and externally that conspire to have your efforts fail.

The notion of centralized planning and decentralized execution has merit in modern software development processes and the business they support. Planning is NOT used in the way agile software developers use the word Planning – wrongly BTW. Planning in the defense domain, for defense processes, and the programs that deliver the systems used in those processes means Strategy Making.

All Planning is Strategy Making. So when you here an agilest say Responding the Change Over Following The Plan, they should really be saying following the schedule. The irony of course is even the formal DoD Earned Value Management world, there is a nice little form titled BCR (Budget Change Request) and its used all the time to make changes to the cost and scehdule baseline. Whym beacuse things change. But if we’re changing our Strategy all the time, then there’s a much bigger problem to solve.

Calculating Outcomes

To follow on a recent theme of what’s wrong with populist book? is shown in this example. Integrating Air, Land, and Sea Operations, which speaks to integration of complex systems into a System of Systems that behaves in ways not definable in the beginning. This is done through intelligent agents at the nodes of the network. This is called network centric warfare.

The Integrated Master Plan (IMP) is a Strategy for the successful completion of the Program. Like all strategies, a set of hypothesis are needed to test the strategy. With these hypothesis testing processes, there is no way to known if the strategy – the Plan – will work.

This is a sample of a book where popular ideas are presented and at the same time actionable outcomes are provided.